MindMap Gallery ACCA_AAA mind map
This is a mind map about ACCA-AAA. This mind map is relatively systematic and comprehensive, and it is expected to pass all subjects. In the July 2020 exam season, 3 AAA SBR AFM subjects can be passed in one go.
Edited at 2021-08-19 20:38:00This is a mind map about bacteria, and its main contents include: overview, morphology, types, structure, reproduction, distribution, application, and expansion. The summary is comprehensive and meticulous, suitable as review materials.
This is a mind map about plant asexual reproduction, and its main contents include: concept, spore reproduction, vegetative reproduction, tissue culture, and buds. The summary is comprehensive and meticulous, suitable as review materials.
This is a mind map about the reproductive development of animals, and its main contents include: insects, frogs, birds, sexual reproduction, and asexual reproduction. The summary is comprehensive and meticulous, suitable as review materials.
This is a mind map about bacteria, and its main contents include: overview, morphology, types, structure, reproduction, distribution, application, and expansion. The summary is comprehensive and meticulous, suitable as review materials.
This is a mind map about plant asexual reproduction, and its main contents include: concept, spore reproduction, vegetative reproduction, tissue culture, and buds. The summary is comprehensive and meticulous, suitable as review materials.
This is a mind map about the reproductive development of animals, and its main contents include: insects, frogs, birds, sexual reproduction, and asexual reproduction. The summary is comprehensive and meticulous, suitable as review materials.
AAA
Part A Audit of historical financial information Key auditing standards
1 audit revision
reasonable assurance
not 100% assurance, because of the inherent limitation, the opinion on evidence is persuasive rather than conclusive
Because there may be some deliberately concealed fraud, which cannot be detected according to formal procedures, it is considered an inherent risk.
in all material respects
impact, nature, value
0.5% revenue, 1% total assets, 5% profit before tax
type of modified opinion
2 audit planning
No need to give advice Risks need to be clearly explained
2.1 accounting issue
Answer format
The focus is on familiarity with IFRS
Matter to consider
1. Materiality ($220m, 1.8% of asset, 3.6% of profit) 2. IAS (as brief as possible!!!) 3. RoMM (This is the key point!!) 4. Impact overstate understate (specific to the subject)
Evidence
If you can combine the data in the case, you should also combine it! For example, 55 executives 1. ASP, action, source, purpose 2. Write in the order of accounting standards, which is more logical. For example, if you want to confirm, you must meet the conditions. Is there any corresponding evidence to meet the conditions? For example, the calculation order of IAS 36, verify the data one by one. 3. Common sense is a bit confusing and can be used as a supplement. For example, if you have a car accident, you need to find an insurance report.
Use inspect more for action and less use review, discuss, and inquire, because these oral evidences are less useful than written evidences.
Remember to write the purpose clearly and in sufficient detail. For example xxxx to confirm the accuracy of research cost of $1.2m
The answer formats of RoMM and audit risk are basically the same.
audit risk = RoMM x detection risk Detection risk includes new guests, DDL is too tight control risk includes IT system, management override
2.2 analytical procedures
Purpose: 1. identify RoMM 2. developing audit strategy and plan
evaluation of financial information through analysis of plausible relationship between financial and non-financial data
Answer template: 1. Main indicators change by xx% 2. Relevant indicators will change by xx% 3. Copy the question and explain whether there are any one-off matters that have changed the indicator (deducted if not) 4. Explain the risks If there is a reason for the change, just mention the reason. If there is no reasonable reason, then there is a risk.
operating margin, ROCE, interest cover, effective tax rate, current ratio, gearing ratio
accumulation
interest
There may be restrictive covenants on borrowing in finance costs, and the restrictive covenants on debt must be disclosed.
Gearing and finance cost are related
tax
The effective tax rate should remain stable
tax = current tax deferred tax. If DTL increases a lot, profit decreases a little, and tax remains unchanged, there is an error.
Unused losses can be offset if there is profit in the next three years, but it may not be used in a certain year.
2.3 business risk
definition: adversely affect an entity's ability to achieve its objectives Have a negative impact on the company's ability to achieve its goals
目标包括:财报、经营、合规
Don’t mention accounting standards, just talk about it from a business level
Answer order: Why is it a risk? → Impact on business and audit → Impact on profit, cash flow, survival (related to F/S)
revenue↓ cost↑ profit↓ reputation↓ cashflow↓ going concern×
accumulation
ratio
Different industries value different ratios
cash flow
Analyze the cash flow statement from top to bottom
overtrading
Revenue rises, but margins fall and liquidity deteriorates - going concern
Financing analysis
What happens if I can’t borrow money later?
3 audit evidence - MJ's approach
Answer ideas
Big deal three brothers
agreement/contract
authorized? ——board minutes
cash book and bank statement
event driven
Contact the specific situation in the case
accounting issue
disclose / confirm / professionally, verify the data one by one according to the calculation order in IFRS. For example, for IAS 36, check carrying amount, recoverable amount, FV, PV
e.g. confirm research expense not be capitalized, confirm the probability of the provision
accumulation
impairment
p47
intangible asset
p53
IFRS 5 non-current assets held for sale and discontinued operations
p62
4 complete the audit
ISA 560: subsequent events
Corresponds to IAS 10: adjusting: existed at the end of the reporting period non-adjusting: after the end of the reporting period
auditor's responsibility: 12.31 ~ 4.28 ~ 4.30 FY sign issue In FY~sign, auditors have the obligation to proactively discover and perform adequate and appropriate audit procedures. In sign~issue, the auditor has no obligation to proactively discover, but if he knows, he must take measures (passive responsibility). There is no obligation.
The audit report can be released before the financial report is released, but not after the financial report, because the audited financial report should be released to the market.
ISA 570: going concern
If it does not survive for 12 months, there is no distinction between long-term and short-term assets, and there is no meaning of depreciation.
Appropriate, but there are serious concerns appropriate, material uncertainty
material uncertainty is adequately disclosed
unqualified but add a material uncertainty related to going concern paragraph
material uncertainty is not adequately disclosed
qualified/adverse
inappropriate inappropriate
adverse, material and pervasive
Audit scope is limited unable to assess
qualified / disclaimer, due to insufficient appropriate evidence
review of audit files
engagement partner / reviewer review
Just know it, it’s usually the main content of the question
ISA 450: evaluation of misstatement identified during the audit
definition
not be treated correctly in accordance with IFRS, 4 kinds of misstatement
amount
classfication
presentation
discontinued operations are not seperated
disclosure
contingent liability disclosure missing
specific requirements and applications
the auditor shall accumulate misstatement identified during the audit, rather than those that are clearly trivial. Obvious trivial misstatements do not need to be accumulated. Misstatements greater than the trivial threshold must be accumulated.
Misstatement type
factual misstatement
no doubt, e.g. clear breach IFRS no doubt did something wrong
judgment misstatement
accounting estimates inappropriateAccounting estimates are inappropriate
projected misstatement
identified misstatement to the entire population from which the sample were drawn Overall misstatements estimated from the test sample - specific misstatements identified in the test
If it is concluded that the misstatement is large, further audit procedures will be performed and the materiality level may be lowered.
It is necessary to communicate with the TCWG. If it does not change, then change the audit report. At the same time, it is necessary to obtain a written representation that does not change. If it does not change, F.S. is still free from material misstatement.
ISA 520: overall review of the financial statements
The audit starts from AP and ends with AP. The first thing is to find the risk points, and the last thing is to see whether the trend is consistent with the imagined understanding.
ISA 720: the auditor's responsibilities relating to other information in documents
When the operating analysis and other non-financial reports in IR are inconsistent with the financial report, you can explain it in the other information paragraph.
ISA 580: written representations
Two basic statements
Provides necessary audit evidence, but is not sufficient
Preparing report FS preparing
We have fulfilled our responsibilities to FS, the accounting estimates have reasonable reasons, related parties have been notified, and subsequent events have been notified. Anything that has not been corrected is just a minor mistake.
information providing
Provide evidence and personnel cooperation for auditors
WP of specific assertion
For virtual management judgment, intentions, future plans → WP is necessary For those with real evidence that can be verified → WP is formal
IFRS 5 held-for-sale has the intention to sell assets in the future. If there is no other evidence, the management can be asked to write a WP guarantee.
When management does not want to correct misstatements, they should be asked to write a WP saying that they believe that if these misstatements are not corrected, it will not cause material misstatements.
5 reporting
basic elements: 1. title 2. addressee 3. opinion paragraph 4. basis for opinion paragraph 5. material uncertainty related to going concern paragraph* 6. emphasis of matter paragraph* 7. key audit matters paragraph 8. other matter paragraph* 9. responsibility of management and those charged with governance for the financial statements 10. auditor's responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements 11. report on other legal and regulatory requirements 12. name of audit engagement partner 13. signature of audit engagement partner and/or audit firm 14. auditor's address 15. date of the auditor’s report
opinions & paragraphs
qualified 'except for' basis for xxx paragraph
Should include the material misstatement amount in the basis for modification paragraph a description and quantification
Material uncertainty related to going concern paragraph
Included only if there are going concern issues
Emphasis of matter paragraph
appropriately presented but it's fundamental to users' understanding to make economic decisions
opinion will not qualified in respect of this matter and will not be modified because of this
cross references, refer to a certain note
Other matter paragraph
If there is some inconsistency between the non-financial report content and the financial report data, say
KAM
definition: in the auditor's professional judgment, the most significant in the audit of the FS of the current period
The matters in the financial statements that, in the auditor's professional judgment, are considered to be the most significant
The purpose is to improve communication between information users and auditors, to tell users what points the auditor paid attention to, why they paid attention, and what audit procedures were used to help users understand.
Only required for listed companies
3 types of KAM
Significant risks, accounting estimates, major transactions
1 areas of higher assess RoMM or significant risk identified
Special risks identified in areas of high significant risk
Special risks: caused by fraud Management overrides internal controls Significant related party transactions beyond normal business scope
2 significant auditor judgment relating to areas in FS involving significant management judgment
Significant management judgment
3 effect on the audit of significant events or transactions
major transactions
phrasing
These matters are the most important matters in the audit of the current period's financial statements, but we express our opinions on the statements as a whole rather than on these matters individually.
auditors' reports to those charged with governance
Things that the auditor should discuss with those charged with governance: the initial scope and timing of the audit, special risks identified, significant issues discovered, difficulties encountered in the audit, matters that management does not want to change, and matters that would modify the audit report Communicate in a timely manner
Two ways to examine reports
matter to discuss with magt, impact on report
Basically it’s the application of accounting standards
Change report
Generally, 30% are minor problems such as heading, and 70% are statement errors and opinion errors.
Part B Other issues in audit Other auditing standards
1 group audits
subsidiary, joint venture, associate
Not being integrated is no excuse not to merge
If the shares have no voting rights, then IAS 28 is not required even up to 25%
Only the person with veto power has control. If it is joint control, it is the JV.
IFRS3 business combination
The merger is a major transaction, and the three brothers are usually used. It mainly depends on whether there are any problems in the goodwill calculation process.
Find out the consideration, NCI, net identifiable asset, and goodwill in the calculation process in order.
Accounting policies of members of the group may differ and require adjustment
A due diligence report may be used in the evidence
IFRS10 consolidated financial statements
Remember to check the URP, starting from two aspects: price and quantity, which may be used to "revitalize" idle inventory.
For group audit, both the parent company and the group must issue reports, 2 copies in total
No goodwill: It may be exactly 0, it may be completely impaired, or it may be calculated incorrectly
ISA 600: special considerations - audits of group financial statement
significant component refers to the following characteristics identified during the group audit:
significant 1: A single component is significant to the group
full trial
significant 2: A single nature or circumstance may lead to a material misstatement in the group
Choose from full review, specific subjects, and specific procedures
For example, if there is foreign currency conversion, although the amount is not significant, miscalculation may have a great impact on other
Because it is inconvenient for component auditor to audit by myself, I use local auditor.
Regarding the ethical level of auditors, are the ethical standards the same overseas? Is sufficient involvement sufficient to obtain evidence? Are local regulations strict?
If there is no significant 1 2, then there is no need to worry about the local audit. Anyway, the impact on the group will be very small, and the responsibility will be shouldered by the component auditor.
But if something goes wrong, the group audit will be fully responsible
matter to consider before accepting appointment as parent company auditor Things to consider before undergoing a group audit
The importance of the group audit part, the RoMM of the component, and the relationship with the component auditor
Difficulties of component abroad: different accounting policies, culture, language
When a component's audit report opinion is modified, the group may not necessarily modify it because it does not necessarily exceed the importance level.
The component materiality group is 5 million, so the component cannot be greater than 5 million, but it doesn’t matter if the sum of them is greater than 5 million.
eg. The subsidiary is pervasive but the group is not extensive, so the subsidiary is adverse but the group is qualified.
joint audit Two companies working on the same project jointly issued an opinion
Reason: It is more convenient for the newly acquired subsidiary to use the original auditor, the area is too large, and the laws of the country where the subsidiary is located require that only local auditors can audit
Remember to check the qualifications of the local firm
The two firms are jointly responsible for the
jointly liable
2 fraud and law
ISA 240: the auditor's responsibilities relating to fraud in an audit of financial statements
1 Definition
Deliberately doing something wrong, there are two kinds, it’s wrong on the surface; it’s gone in reality.
2 Responsibilities
Auditors do not check for fraud, only management does. Auditor is required to obtain reasonable assurance that the FS is free from MM whether caused by fraud or error. As long as there is reasonable assurance, it will be unreasonable if the fraud reaches a very high level. Auditing The teacher has no responsibility
keep professional skepticism, difficult to detect, deliberate hidden, appropriate procedure could not detect fraud
questioning mind, alert, critical assessment, related party, management bias
3 Risk assessment procedures
Ask management about their risk assessment, fraud triangle (motivation opportunity dishonesty), and assume there is a fraud risk.
4 Dealing with risks caused by fraud
change the nature of audit procedure(more physical observation and inspection) timing assault Do more work All three are designed to increase unpredictability
5 measures to detect fraud
Fraud is not an isolated incident. If one amount is changed, there may be many others that need to be changed. The appropriateness of the process that has been done needs to be re-evaluated, taking into account the nature of fraud.
6 Communicate with superiors
For example, if a manager commits fraud, he must report it to the general manager.
ISA 250: consideration of laws and regulations in an audit of financial statements
Comply with two types of regulations: 1. Tax law, pensions 2. It has no direct impact on the amount and disclosure but has a significant impact on sustainable operating capabilities (the focus of this section)
1 Responsibility
Management has full responsibility, auditors are only responsible for statements
The auditor must collect sufficient and appropriate audit evidence for above 1 (because they are the subjects in the statement) Only perform specific audit procedures on above 2 to identify significant risk behaviors
2 auditor's consideration of compliance with laws
Understand the regulations of the client's industry, how to comply with regulations, laws that have a significant impact on statements, laws that have an impact on business activities (environmental protection), if any violation is found, ask the lawyer, management, etc., and the impact of the law involves estimation , if you have an estimate, you can use WP
3 when discover possible non-compliance
understand the nature of act and circumstances further evidence
evaluate the impact, if management does not take remedial action, can withdraw from the engagement, the impact refers to the impact on the report
4 report the identified or suspected non-compliance
discuss with TCWG as soon as possible, because it may deliberate and potential seriousness
report to third party if necessary
Answer order: Facts→Understand the law→More evidence→impact to FS→TCWG→threat intimidation→Internal control→seek legal advice
professional liability
Regarding negligent negligence, who claims it and who gives evidence?
duty of care, breached, cause loss
Prove 3 points: all are indispensable, and there is a responsibility, but the responsibility was violated and certain losses were caused.
Auditors naturally have a duty of care towards their clients, because this is stipulated in the contract. Nonsense!
joint and several liabilities
If an executive commits fraud and neither the BOD nor the auditor finds it, they can sue any one of them, and the one who is sued will find others to share the burden.
managing exposure to liability
disclaimer of liability, liability limitation agreement, limited compensation agreement, common in practice, used to avoid some risks
money laundering
definition
process by which criminal attempt to conceal the true origin and ownership of the proceeds of their criminal activity
3 stages
Placement is placed in an industry suitable for money laundering, and layering makes people unclear about the source. For example, if it is remitted overseas, integration and move back
money lauding offences
report to MLRO, training, tipping off offence, due diligence, maintain records
3 using the work of others
The use of internal audits is very similar to the work of experts. In fact, internal audits can also be regarded as internal experts.
ISA 610: using the work of internal auditors
Look at the status and independence of the internal audit, whether the soul is clean, whether the competency is capable, and whether the method used by the internal audit is a good systematic and disciplined approach
Procedures required when relying on internal audit: 1. Obtain the written consent of the company 2. Obtain written consent from the internal auditor and identify ways to handle ethical conflicts when they arise
Relying on the work of internal audit does not relieve the firm of its responsibility, and it cannot be said to be relying on internal audit in the audit report
ISA 620: using the work of an auditor's expert
Whether the expert is independent, objective, experienced or competent, the scope of the expert’s work, and the appropriateness of the expert’s work, the relevance of conclusions
The two are actually similar and can be used to assist memory Ethics must be objective, capabilities, scope of work, and methods of use Take independent responsibility for audit opinions and do not reduce responsibilities by using the work of internal auditors and experts
4 specific accounting issues
ISA 540: auditing accounting estimates, including fair value accounting estimates and related disclosuresAccounting estimates
1 Nature and definition
2 programs
Understand the standards, understand which transactions require accounting estimates, and understand how management makes estimates.
3 Identify and assess risks
Auditors assess the degree of uncertainty to see whether accounting estimates with a high degree of uncertainty result in special risks
4 Dealing with risks
Is there any relevant evidence?
5 further SP
sensitivity analysis
ISA 550: related parties transactions
Abnormal terms, lack of business substance, lack of a logical business reason, and large volumes may all be related party transaction risks.
1 Risk assessment
Concealed, beyond the normal scope of business
Must check bank receipts, confirmation letters, shareholder and governance meeting minutes
2 Identify and assess the risk of material misstatement
3 Dealing with risks
Check the contract, evaluate the business rationale of the contract, transaction terms and management's explanation, and see if there is proper disclosure. The three brothers' authorization learned before does not apply here, because authorization does not mean that there is no fraud.
ISA 510: initial audit engagements - opening balances first audit
Specifically refers to the first audit. The goal is to see whether the opening balance contains misstatements that have a significant impact on the current period's financial report, whether the accounting policies at the beginning of the period have been consistently applied in the current period, and if IAS 8 has changed, have there been changes in the current period?
Many questions say it is new client You can use these at this time
This will involve detection risk At the same time, there is also DDL tight
Is the carry-forward correct at the end of the previous period? Whether the accounting policy is correctly used or not? Application; Audit report of the previous period
predecessor auditor, professional clearance communication, the one in the triangle
All are based on a risk-oriented framework Risk assessment, identifying risks, responding to risks
Part C Other assignments Other services other than firm audit
1 audit-related services and other assurance services
provided assurance
In the firm, only auditing (reporting, internal control) gives positive assurance, and the others are limited assurance. Negative form of expression, reasonable assurance, limited assurance
Reasonable assurance in our opinion internal control is effective, in all material respects, based on XYZ criteria
Limited warranty nothing has come to our attention that causes us to believe that internal control is not effective, in all material respects, based on XYZ criteria
You need to be able to write two sentence patterns and compare them
limited assurance review - financial information review
After the company reaches the standard, it must conduct an audit, but before it reaches the standard, it can make simple preparations - review
Review is a limited guarantee, simply AP and ask will do
Comparison with audit 1 Mandatory and non-mandatory 2. Determination of scope audit is guided by ISA, and the review is determined through negotiation between the firm and the client. 3 nature of procedure audit wide review only AP and inquiry 4 reasonable and moderate level. Those who use a lot of programs are reasonable guarantees, and those who don’t use so many programs are moderate (moderate or medium).
due diligence reviews Due diligence
A special review, in order for the acquiring party to understand all the information of the acquired party and define risks. Of course, the acquired party can also understand the acquiring party.
purpose of due diligence
1 information gathering: ensure that the acquirer has full knowledge of the financial and non-financial of the target company
2 verification of management representation: Confirm the information provided by the vendor (the merged party)
3 identification of asset and liability pricing
4 operational issues depends on operational capabilities
5. Acquisition planning favors investment banks, synergy, and post-investment management.
benefit ofDD
Providing DD externally can make executives more efficient, reduce deviations, improve credibility, and be used for loans
DD VS audit
1range of sources used: DD has a wide range but not so deep. DD also does non-financial
2 level of assurance: DD generally does not express opinions unless requested by the customer. Any opinions are also limited guarantees.
3 types of procedure performed: DD only does inquiry and AP same as review
4 forward looking vs mainly historical: DD predicts the future, audit confirms history
5 no controls testing: DD does not need to check internal controls unless required
Ideas and vocabulary accumulation areas to focus on and additional information Acquisition feasibility equity owners, whether they have VC or not. If they have VC, they are more likely to sell in the future. Reason for acquisition motivation of acquisition for synergy Acquisition valuation FV of net asset, internally generated intangible asset, tangible asset, contingent liability
2 prospective financial information
ISAE 3400: the examination of prospective financial information
Audits of forecasting future data are generally done by firms for the outside world, for shareholders and banks to see, and for financing needs.
Factors to consider before accepting PFI business
In terms of ethics: If there is financing, there will be threats of advocacy. If you do good things directly for the enterprise, there will be threats of advocacy.
competence and time frame Does the firm have the talent and time to do this? What is the subject of identification? Do you need to issue a report? Is the intended user for the bank? general use or limited use Assumptions used in predictions will not be accepted if they are too radical.
Limited warranty
Answer format
Generic answer 1. See if the person doing the forecast has competency 2. cast, confirm accuracy 3. Is the accounting policy consistent with the previous one?
Question types
Can you pick up customers?
How to check forecast
3 forensic audits
Fraud investigation, quantifying financial losses; if the firm is sued, ask another firm to investigate
Things to consider are similar to audits. You can start with the price and quantity of stolen items.
4 social, environmental and public sector auditing
ISA 250 is similar. Failure to comply will have two consequences: provision will be fined and assets will be restricted. Auditors are not solely responsible for social responsibility reports, but they must understand the impact of factors on FS and assess risks, such as provision
Related SPs: documentary review: minutes, publicly available information, report by environmental expert, IA, lawyer...
performance information in the public sector
measurable and relevant
Audit of performance information to see if the information provided is correct to increase credibility Performance auditing is a bit like 3E VFM to see if the target has been achieved←This is what the AAA exam takes
5 internal audit and outsourcing
p294 Advantages and Disadvantages
6 service organizations
The client outsources the department. Because the auditor has no direct relationship with the outsourcing company, it is difficult to communicate.
To understand the outsourcer’s risks, the outsourcer’s audit report is also evidence
Part D Professional and ethical issue Morality
1 ethics
Definition of principle and threat
Answer template
1. Identify the cause, self-interest threat, why it's a threat 2. Evaluate reason, materiality 3. Citing code, according to IESBA, the auditor should not... 4. measures, safeguard
Common moral conflicts
- Financial interest - Providing services outside of the main business, such as Apple providing auditors with foot-washing services - Business relationship with audit client holds lecture tours with clients and does business together personal relationship - Too long engagement, more than 7 years - Provide accounting related services - Recruitment collects money - Help customers keep their assets
2 quality control 2018/6 Q3
Specifically refers to the quality control within the firm, ISQC, Carry out quality control according to accept (ethic, competency, experience), plan (team human resource), field work (supervision), report (review), and you can write answers according to the audit process. (No special preparation is required. It is analyzed based on previous knowledge. It is somewhat similar to checking deficiencies. Deficiencies belong to the company and QC belongs to the firm)
- QC reviewer is also QC partner. It should be greater than or equal to engagement partner before you can review him. - Look at the cases and write only if there are some in the cases. Don’t overextend, otherwise it will become just a conjecture. - Being relatives with the customer employees, there is a threat of familyship and objective influence. - Only important matters need to be reported to the management, not important matters.
3 Obtaining and accepting professional appointments
Regulations on business solicitation by firms
Notes on answering questions AAA attaches great importance to the quality of answers
materiality
This is an easy mark, and you don’t need to write it very long. The fixed format is as follows development cost is material ($300m, 5% profit, 3% of asset)
Pay attention to application
Just pick out a relevant small point in the guidelines, there is no need to memorize the entire guidelines IAS 38 technical feasibility has not proven, therefore the cost of $300m can not capitalized.
Impact is written to the corresponding subject
therefore the intangible asset has been overstated, and expense be understated by $300m.
link to case
Correspond to industry
expert should have the experience in the fruit tree valuation, has biological qualification
Correspond to specific numbers
the qualified 55 directors should be calculated Instead the staffs should be calculated
Write and analyze in depth
the online sale discount rate may not update in the accounting system, the revenue may forget to calculate the discount. instead of the discount will lead the revenue misstatement.
More points linked together rather than isolated (relatively difficult)
the valuer should be objective, but the BoD is consist by family, therefore the valuer may appoint has relationship will the family instead of the value should be without financial or personal link with company
Format points
report to BoD of xxx Co introduction (briefly copy the question) heading xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx conclusion (briefly summarize the problems found) report compiled by date
To: xxx From: xxx Subject: xxx introduction (briefly copy the question) heading xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx conclusion (briefly summarize the problems found)