Corporate Performance Management Guide
1. Basic theory of performance management
1. Performance Management Definition and Core Objectives
- Definition: Improve the management system of organizational and individual performance by setting goals, monitoring processes, and evaluating results
- Core Objectives:
▶ Strategic implementation: break down organizational goals into executable tasks
▶ Efficiency improvement: Optimize resource allocation and reduce operating costs
▶ Talent Development: Identify high-potential employees and provide directions for improvement
▶ Cultural Shaping: Strengthening Results-oriented and Continuous Improvement Ambient
2. The difference between performance management and performance appraisal
| Dimensions | Performance Management | Performance Appraisal |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Cycle | Full process (PDCA cycle) | Phase (quarterly/year) |
| Focus | Goal setting Process tutoring Results application | Results evaluation Rewards and punishments |
| Direction | Future performance improvement | Past performance evaluation |
| Participation | All-in-one participation (employment) | Manager-led |
3. Three theoretical foundations of performance management
- Target Management Theory (MBO, Drucker): Emphasizes goal decomposition and self-control
- Contingency theory: Adjust the performance system according to corporate strategy and cultural dynamics
- Motivation Theory (Herzberg two-factor): Design performance indicators for distinguishing health care factors from motivational factors
2. Analysis of the entire process of performance management
1. Performance Plan Development (P-Plan)
- Goal setting principle: SMART principle (specific, measurable, achievable, relevance, time limit)
- Target decomposition path:
▶ Strategic Map: From corporate vision to strategic themes (such as balanced scorecards)
▶ Target tree: Organizational goals → Department goals → Personal goals (Example: Revenue goals → Sales department goals → Sales personal indicators)
- Tools: Target decomposition matrix, performance contract book, Gantt chart
2. Performance Process Monitoring (D-Do)
- Monitoring method:
▶ Regular meetings: weekly meetings/monthly meetings track progress (such as Alibaba’s “Review Culture”)
▶ Data board: Real-time update of KPI completion rate (such as Tableau visualization)
▶ Walking management: On-site observation and guidance of managers (such as General Electric’s “Collaboration” meeting)
- Tutoring skills: GROW model (goal setting → current situation analysis → plan selection → action planning)
3. Performance evaluation implementation (C-Check)
- Evaluation subject: 360-degree evaluation (superior, colleague, subordinate, customer)
- Evaluation cycle:
▶ Grassroots employees: monthly/quarterly assessment
▶ Management: Semi-annual/annual assessment
▶ Project-based positions: Assessed by project cycle
- Evaluation method: mandatory distribution method, key event method, behavioral anchoring method
4. Performance feedback improvement (A-Action)
- Feedback Principle:
▶ Definitely: Use data to speak with facts (such as "Q3 sales are 15% lower than target")
▶ Positive guidance: Focus on improvement rather than criticism (such as "we can improve conversion through XX method")
▶ Two-way communication: Encourage employees to self-assess (such as “What aspects do you think are doing well at this stage?”)
- Improvement tools: PDCA cycle, performance improvement plan (PIP), capability improvement matrix
3. Core methods of performance management
1. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
- Definition: Quantitative evaluation of organization/personal performance through key indicators
- Design steps:
1. Determine enterprise-level KPIs (such as ROE, customer satisfaction)
2. Decompose to departments (such as marketing department: brand exposure, customer acquisition cost)
3. Implement to individuals (such as sales: signing volume, collection rate)
- Pros and cons:
▶ Advantages: clear goals, easy to quantify, and aligned with strategy
▶ Disadvantages: It is easy to ignore non-quantitative capabilities and may trigger short-term behavior
- Case: Huawei's "customer-centered" KPI system
2. Goals and Key Results Method (OKR)
- Definition: Objective Agile management method for key outcomes (KRs)
- Implementation points:
▶ Target setting: Focus on 3-5 strategic goals (such as "Q4 to improve daily active users of e-commerce platforms")
▶ Key Results: Each target matches 2-4 measurable results (such as "daily active growth of 20%")
▶ Cycle: Quarterly update, annual review
- Pros and cons:
▶ Advantages: Inspire innovation, adapt to change, and promote cross-departmental collaboration
▶ Disadvantages: High requirements for employee autonomy and need to be used with supporting KPIs
- Case: Google OKR implements four-step method (alignment → disassembly → tracking → review)
3. Balanced Scorecard (BSC)
- Definition: Measure performance from four dimensions, finance, customers, internal processes, learning and growth
- Dimensional analysis:
▶ Finance: revenue growth rate, profit margin, etc.
▶ Customers: NPS value, repurchase rate, etc.
▶ Internal processes: process optimization rate, project delivery cycle, etc.
▶ Learning and Growth: Employee training time, patent application quantity, etc.
- Implementation steps: Draw a strategic map → Design indicators → Develop an action plan
- Case: Mobil Oil improves customer loyalty by 15% through BSC
4. Other methods
- Economic Value Added (EVA): Measures corporate value creation (EVA=Net operating profit after tax - cost of capital)
- 360-degree feedback: Comprehensive assessment of behavioral capabilities (applicable to managerial capacity development)
- Points management: Quantitative daily behaviors (such as attendance, innovative proposal points redemption rewards)
4. Performance management tools and technologies
1. Digital tools
- Performance Platform:
▶ UFIDA YonBIP: Supports KPI settings, process tracking, and automatic scoring
▶ Kingdee Cloud·Xinghan: Integrated OKR management module to update progress in real time
- Data board:
▶ Indicator monitoring: Power BI displays the completion rate of key indicators in real time
▶ Early warning mechanism: DingTalk/Enterprise WeChat automatically pushes abnormal reminders
- Mobile Apps:
▶ Record at any time: Submit key events and milestones through the APP
▶ Mobile approval: online approval process for performance evaluation
2. Analytical model
- Boston Matrix: Evaluating Performance from Market Share and Growth Rate
- SWOT analysis: identify advantages and improvement points based on performance results
- Attribution analysis: Trace the reasons for performance deviation through fishbone diagram (such as "salary decline" attributed to competitor impact and team loss)
3. Institutional tools
- Performance management system: clarify the process, cycle, and responsible subjects
- Performance grievance mechanism: employee feedback channel for evaluation results
- Performance Archives Management: Record employee performance throughout the cycle
5. Performance management implementation steps
1. Preparation phase (weeks 1-2)
- Establish a special team: HR business department Senior leaders
- Current status diagnosis: Identify management pain points through questionnaire surveys and high-level interviews
- Develop a plan: choose an adaptation method (such as starting companies give priority to OKR, mature companies use KPI BSC)
2. Training phase (weeks 3-4)
- Management Training: Understanding performance management concepts and tools (such as OKR workshops)
- Employee publicity: Explain the process and evaluation standards (such as making an animation demonstration of "Performance Manual")
- Pilot operation: Select 1-2 departments to verify the feasibility of the plan first
3. Implementation phase (weeks 5-36)
- Goal setting: Align organization and individual goals through workshops
- Process Management: Conduct monthly performance counseling meetings to record key events
- Data collection: Each department has designated a dedicated person to summarize performance data
4. Assessment phase (weeks 37-40)
- Self-evaluation and other evaluation: Employee self-evaluation, superior scoring, cross-departmental feedback
- Calibration meeting: High-level review of evaluation results to avoid scoring deviations
- Results announcement: Confirm performance levels with employees and sign a performance feedback form
5. Application phase (weeks 41-44)
- Salary linkage: Performance salary = basic salary × performance coefficient (such as coefficient range 0.8-1.2)
- Promotion reference: Priority promotion for performance S-level promotion for two consecutive years
- Training development: formulate personalized training plans based on capabilities shortcomings
6. Optimization Phase (weeks 45-52)
- Satisfaction survey: Collect employee suggestions for improvement of performance system
- Effectiveness Assessment: Comparison of key indicators before and after implementation (such as a 5% decrease in employee turnover rate)
- Solution iteration: Adjust indicators and processes according to business changes
6. Frequently Asked Questions and Solutions for Performance Management
1. Unreasonable goal setting
- Problem performance: The indicator is too high or too low, out of touch with the strategy
- Solution:
▶ Strategic decoding meeting: Use the onion peeling method to decompose the target (enterprise → department → individual)
▶ Historical data reference: Set the floating range based on the average level of the past 3 years
▶ Employee participation: Set goals through the "upper and down" method (such as submitting the first draft from the bottom up)
2. Process monitoring is missing
- Problem manifestation: At the end of the period, the lack of process guidance
- Solution:
▶ Establish a "mile mark" mechanism: set small goals at each stage (such as splitting the quarterly target into monthly milestones)
▶ Manager's performance report: Regularly report on the counseling status of subordinates (such as submitting the "Guiding Record" every month)
▶ Digital tracking: Real-time update progress through project management tools
3. Dispute in the evaluation results
- Problem manifestation: Employees do not approve of the score, causing conflicts
- Solution:
▶ Standardization of performance interviews: Feedback using STAR rules (situation → task → action → result)
▶ Appeal process: Establish a three-level appeal mechanism (directly subordinate superiors → HR → management)
▶ Scoring calibration: Compare the scoring scale across departments to avoid "loose/strict error"
4. Single result application
- Problem manifestation: only used to issue bonuses, ignoring development value
- Solution:
▶ Establish a “performance-competency” matrix: identifying high potential and employees to be improved
▶ Career development channel: Performance results are directly linked to promotion and rotation
▶ Training requirements analysis: Design personalized learning paths based on evaluation results
7. Performance Management and Organizational Development
1. Performance and Talent Inventory
- Nine-Classification of Talents:
▶ Horizontal axis: Performance level (A/B/C), vertical axis: Capability potential (high/medium/low)
▶ Application: Identify celebrity employees (A high potential), optimize low-performance employees (C low potential)
- Successor Plan: Develop a cross-departmental training plan for high-potential talents
2. Performance and cultural construction
- Shaping a performance culture:
▶ Benchmark management: Establish a "Performance Star" case library (such as the best project team of the quarter)
▶ Transparent announcement: Internal publications announce outstanding performance results
▶ Ceremony Design: Annual Performance Award Ceremony
3. Performance and Digital Transformation
- Data-driven decision-making:
▶ Talent data analysis: Use AI to predict high-risk employees (such as performance drops sharply and attendance abnormalities)
▶ Dynamic indicator adjustment: Automatically trigger the indicator calibration process when market changes
- Blockchain application: Untampered performance data storage to enhance credibility
8. Performance management development trends
1. Trend of Agility
- Dynamic target adjustment: Reset OKR every quarter according to market changes
- Micro performance evaluation: record key contributions daily/weekly (such as real-time update of ByteDance's "Fly Shu OKR")
2. Lightweight tools
- Minimalist indicators: Each position has no more than 5 core indicators
- Gamified design: Points and medal system improves participation (such as "performance pass" to get virtual rewards)
3. Employee experience priority
- Self-service performance: employee self-select evaluation cycle and indicator weight
- Positive feedback: emphasizing "growth thinking" and reducing punitive measures
4. Sustainable Performance
- ESG integration: Incorporate environmental, social and governance indicators into the performance system
- Long-termism: Setting strategic performance indicators for 3-5 years (such as technical patent accumulation)
9. Analysis of practical cases
1. Huawei: Responsibility-oriented performance management
- Core logic:
▶ Three-tier assessment: company-level KPI → departmental PRD (performance reference document) → personal PBC (personal performance commitment)
▶ Last-place elimination: 5% of employees in each department enter the performance improvement process
- Features: Team Assessment Culture of "Winning, Raising Glass to Celebrate; Failing, Stop Saving"
2. ByteDance: OKR Feishu's agile management
- Implementation points:
▶ Target Alignment: Achieve cross-departmental OKR transparency through Feishu
▶ Real-time tracking: Update KR progress every week and automatically generate progress reports
- Results: Per capita OKR completion rate has increased to 85%, and project iteration speed has accelerated by 30%
3. Haier: "People-in-one" performance model
- Innovation points:
▶ Subverting the bureaucracy: Employee performance is directly linked to user value ("single" refers to user needs)
▶ Independent business: small and micro teams set their own goals, self-organized teams, and self-distributed income
- Effect: Inventory turnover days dropped from 30 days to 7 days, and user satisfaction increased by 40%
Wondershare EdrawMind
